Shop Where To Buy Recipes Articles About Spiciest in Columbus Contact Us

Where To Find Our Hot Sauce

As we continue on our spicy adventure, we’re always looking for new friends to collaborate with or locations to keep our sauces even closer to you. Below is our ever-growing list of where you can find Fartley Farms hot sauce.


  • Atlas Tavern (Wing sauces and HELL IS REAL Grilled Cheese)
    8944 Lyra Dr
    Columbus, OH 43240
  • The Butcher & Grocer
    1089 W 1st Ave
    Grandview Heights, OH 43212
  • Jungle Jim’s (Fairfield)
    5440 Dixie Hwy,
    Fairfield, OH 45014
  • Jungle Jim’s (Eastgate)
    4450 Eastgate S Dr
    Cincinnati, OH 45245
  • North Market – Flavor & Fire
    59 Spruce St
    Columbus, OH 43215
  • Ohio Art Market
    30 N State St
    Westerville, OH 43081
  • Specialty Gas House
    4500 Indianola Ave
    Columbus, OH 43214

Atlas Tavern

Featured in their “World’s Greatest Wings” section, you can find our Ginger Reaper or Serrano Garlic sauces to coat your Unforgettable Traditional Wings, Legendary Boneless Wings, or Cauliflower Wings. Our Serrano Garlic sauce also spices up the “Hell Is Real” Grilled Cheese sandwich, named after the big billboard along I-71 near Mt. Sterling.atlas tavern menu items with fartley farms hot sauce

The Butcher & Grocer

We’ve been an admirer of The Butcher & Grocer‘s meats for quite a while. With custom sausages (some with super hot peppers inside), locally sourced meats, and a solid array of Ohio cheeses, we’re pumped to be on the shelves. Follow them on Instagram for their latest meaty messages.

Flavor & Fire – North Market (Downtown Columbus, OH)

The number one hot shop in Columbus, we’re on the same shelves as former local legend CaJohn’s, Spice Pepper Co., Clam Lube, and the store’s namesake Flavor and Fire.

Flower City Flavor Company

Based in New York, Flower City Flavor Company is home to a broad array of hot sauces from Adoboloco to Whitehouse Station and also us! Flower City Flavor Company is another great option for scooping up various brands in one online storefront.

fartley farms on flower city flavor company


Jungle Jim’s International Market

We are so pumped for this one. Jungle Jim’s has one of the largest hot sauce selections we’ve ever seen and has an entire “Ohio Proud” section where we’re featured alongside Flavor & Fire, Clamlube, Juicymelt Supreme, and several others. Thankfully Jungle Jim’s also alphabetizes their gigantic selection, making it easy to find us. We’re in the F’s if that wasn’t clear. Find us right before Fat Cat!

Ohio Art Market (Westerville)

As of March 5, 2021, you can now find us right by the checkout counter with some other Columbus food products. Ohio Art Market has been in historic uptown Westerville since Summer 2011. The store features Ohio Artists & Artisans and offers an extensive variety of hand made items. We have original art, jewelry, home goods and gourmet treats for you & your furry friends along with wonderful things that are uniquely Westerville. Come in and find the perfect unique gift made right here in Ohio!

Specialty Gas House

“Here at Specialty Gas House, we believe that nothing is more important than giving you, our customer, the best service, the best quality products and the highest level of professional customer service we can provide.” We’re pumped to get on the shelves with their other rubs and grilling condiments. Currently they are carrying our Serrano Garlic, Sweet Habanero, and Ginger Reaper.